An employee comes back from medical leave. Their manager is concerned they can’t perform certain physical functions. Should the manager request all their medical records?
Probably not. But you still need to be cautious about safety in the workplace.
Occupational health exams can help you find answers to a specific question at work.
What you’ll learn:
- Begin With Your Safety Issue
- Understand When You Can Order An Occupational Health Exam
- Only Ask Questions Pertaining To Job Functions
- How To Keep Employees Medical Information Confidential At Work
- How To Use Those Results
- Steps Managers Should Take When Dealing With These Situations
Begin With Your Safety Issue
Workplace safety should be taken very seriously. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics there were 2.5 million cases of nonfatal workplace injuries and illnesses among U.S. private-industry employers in 2024.
It’s unclear whether some of these could have been avoided with a medical exam.
What did occur in the workplace? That should be your first line of inquiry, rather than whether they have a medical issue.
Your manager may have seen them trying to use a piece of equipment unsafely. This is not the same as your coworkers’ assumption about a medical diagnosis.
Make sure to look at what they are doing on the job as well. Unsafe machinery, lack of training and improper instructions can also cause safety concerns.
Note the incident, what job function was affected and what the safety concern is. Your HR department can gather facts from this.
In the meantime you can take precautions to help ensure safety in the workplace. Consider a temporary task change only if the observed risk justifies it, wait until you receive more information.
Understand When You Can Order An Occupational Health Exam
The Americans with Disabilities Act (ADA) provides rules on medical exams and inquiries about disabilities that must be followed by covered employers in the United States. Employees who currently work for your company typically can only be examined if it is job-related and consistent with business necessity.
This can include having factual evidence to believe that an employee’s medical condition may affect their ability to complete their job duties or may pose a direct threat to others. If they request an accommodation, you may be able to get more medical information. Or certain laws may require you to do so.
Once you meet these criteria, you can use employee fitness for duty screening to determine if your employee can safely complete the required job functions. The results may also identify needed work restrictions.
For example your employee may have injured their shoulder. Ordering them to complete a fitness for duty exam could allow you to know what they can and cannot lift at work. That does not require disclosure of unrelated medical conditions.
Not every employee will need to be tested if they are underperforming. Use objective, job-related evidence when deciding to send an employee for a medical exam.
If they recently came back from medical leave, you should have a reasonable belief based on objective evidence that they may not be able to do their job or pose a direct threat to others before ordering a medical exam.
Make sure to check with your local laws if your job requires employees to complete safety exams as well.
Only Ask Questions Pertaining To Job Functions
If you decide to send your employee for an occupational health exam, make sure you know what to ask them to look for.
Tell the clinician what job functions they should be able to perform, what their job requires and what your safety concern is. Do not tell them what you think the issue is.
Make sure your job description is up to date as well. If you no longer require your employees to lift heavy objects and have a machine that does this for them, don’t send the clinician an outdated job description.
You could ask if your employee can:
- Lift and carry objects that their job may require
- Operate machinery that may cause harm if done incorrectly
- Wear PPE properly and safely
- Complete their job with certain restrictions
Then ask them to provide you with what they can and can’t do at work and if any job functions need to be put on hold.
You will need this information to make an informed decision about their work schedule or machines they are allowed to use.
Make sure your decision makers know what restrictions they may have to work with and when they may be able to review them again.
If they aren’t asking for an accommodation you need a lawful, job-related reason to request some medical information. It will depend on why you are requesting it.
How To Keep Employees Medical Information Confidential At Work
Just because you have the results of an exam does not mean you can share that with others.
This goes for information that your employee may give you as well. If they tell you about a procedure they had, that doesn’t mean you should post it to your team’s group chat.
The ADA states that you must keep medical information about your employee confidential and stored separately from their personnel file. Some information may be shared with supervisors who need to know about work restrictions or accommodations. Also safety professionals may need to be informed in some situations.
If an employee can only stand for a specified period, your shift supervisor should be informed of that. They probably don’t need to know why.
Keep employee medical files locked, have restricted access to digital copies and don’t send medical results to a team wide email chain. Make sure your managers know how to use this information.
What about HIPAA? HIPAA does not typically apply to medical information an employer may have on their employees. But it does apply to disclosures made by healthcare providers and health plans.
You still need to follow the ADA and state laws that may apply.
How To Use Those Results
Medical results should help you make a decision about your employee’s job.
If they can only do light duties for the time being, see if you can modify their job, equipment or hours to accommodate them.
You may need to consider accommodations if the ADA applies to your situation. You should not assume that they can’t do their job because they have a certain diagnosis.
If there is a safety concern you should also act cautiously when deciding to remove an employee from their duties. The ADA states you must individually evaluate the risk and make a decision based on factual evidence. You will need to consider how long the risk will be present, severity, probability and immediacy of the harm that could occur and if it can be reduced with an accommodation.
If you are unsure how the medical findings affect specific duties you can always ask the examining clinician for clarification. Be sure to document why you are making your decision.
Talk to your employee about what they feel they can do. They may be able to offer insight on how to complete their job. Or let you know what you can modify for them to safely complete their job. Let them know what will be reviewed before making your next decision.
Steps Managers Should Take When Dealing With These Situations
Sometimes companies have great policies in place, but their managers are asking inappropriate questions to employees in front of others.
Make sure your steps to handle these situations are easy to follow.
- Identify and note: What facts did you see occur in the workplace that caused a safety concern?
- Send to HR/Occupational Health Physician: Send your safety concern to your HR department or designated occupational health physician privately.
- Inform Employee: Let the employee know that you are sending them for an occupational health exam and what job functions you would like them to be evaluated for.
- Make Decision And Note: Once you receive information back that is pertinent to the job you can make your decision. Be sure to document your decision and when it will be reviewed.
Have someone responsible for keeping these files safe and following proper legal guidelines for storing them.
Remember that consistency does not mean every decision should be the same.
Conclusion
There is no need to know everything about your employee’s medical history to have a safe work environment.
Find out what the safety issue is, only ask for information that you can justify and keep it confidential. Then make a decision that works for that employee.




